Top 17 Best Butter Keepers Reviews In 2020

Imagining that you want to enjoy your toast and butter for breakfast, however, you forget to soften the butter last night. That problem can be solved with a butter keeper.

With it, you might use the butter anytime you need it without softening it before.

This article provides you with a list of the best 17 butter keepers with detailed reviews for each product. Especially if you are in need of a butter keeper, it will be helpful.

Read more:

• Top 17 Best Enzyme Cleaner Reviews In 2020
• Top 17 Best Sausage Stuffer Reviews In 2020
• Top 18 Best Pizza Cutters Reviews In 2020
• Top 18 Best Kitchen Timers Reviews In 2020

Best Butter Keepers Comparison Chart 2020

This comparison chart is a comprehensive summary of the best butter keepers listed above.

 What Are The Best Butter Keepers To Buy?

Let’s take a quick glance at all the best butter keepers that I’m about to introduce in this article. Here I attach them with a few key features, so you can get a few basic information about each product.

• Best Overall: The Original Butter Bell Butter Keepers
  
• Best Budget: Norpro Glazed Stoneware Butter Keepers
  
• Best Plastic Dish: OXO Good Grips Butter Keepers
  
• Best Crock: Sweese 304.101 Butter Keepers
  
• Best Stoneware: Le Creuset PG0200-0967 Butter Keepers
  
• Best Glass: Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Keepers
  
• Best Square: Now Designs Butter Keepers
  
• Best Boat: Trudeau 09607081A Butter Keepers
  
• Best Design: Butterie Flip-Top Butter Keepers
  
• Best Bay: Butter Bay American Made Butter Keepers
  
• Best Vintage Style: SveBake Butter Keepers
  
• Best Ceramic: KooK Ceramic Butter Keepers
  
• Best Decoration: DOWAN Porcelain Butter Keepers
  
• Best Standard: Rubbermaid Standard Butter Keepers
  
• Best Modern: PREPWORKS Butter Keepers
  

Top 17 Best Butter Keepers Reviews In 2020

Here are some in-depth reviews about each of the best butter keepers after you’ve read some basic information about them. Read more and consider the perfect option!

Butterie Flip-Top Butter Keepers

The first item among the best butter keepers I would recommend is the Butterie Flip-Top Butter Dish Keeper. I was impressed by its unique design and useful features.

Although this butter keeper has compact shape and light weight, the interior can contain up to two butter sticks. It is very convenient for you because there is no need to replenish butter many times.

Unlike other butter keepers with a separate lid, this product has a one-piece design with a flip-top lid. Hecce, butter is kept fresh constantly and the countertop is always clean. There is also a bumper on the back to prevent crashing against your countertop when you flip it open.

It has a non-slip base for the butter area, which makes it easy for you to slice the butter without worrying about it slipping off the dish. Moreover, the two-side handle also allows you to move it around for your convenience.

This butter keeper is made of non-BPA plastic so it is definitely safe for your health. It’s dishwasher-and-microwave friendly therefore you’ll definitely have more options for cleaning. Its high-quality material is also shatterproof.

What makes me satisfied with this product is that it comes with a matching butter spreader. The handy butter spreader is designed with a special cradle in the front of the dish and a hidden wall to scrape butter away from the spreader cleanly.

Overall, this is a great product, with many advantages and special features. I would definitely recommend this if you are thinking of buying one butter keeper.

Product Specs

Rubbermaid Standard Butter Keepers

What a standard butter keeper! If you prefer a plastic butter keeper to avoid breaking, Rubbermaid Standard Butter Keeper is a good option.

Both the cover and the base are made from thick food grade plastic, which means it is durable and ready to serve you in long term.

This product is created to store butter in the best way. A tight lid prevents butter from mold and bacteria. Thus, the butter is kept fresh and tender for a long period of time.

There is a lip around the base to prevent the butter from slipping off the dish when you slice it. However, sometimes, it can be difficult to open due to this feature..

Although it has a simple design, I think this standard butter keeper will preserve butter well and keep it soft at room temperature.

Product Specs

Norpro Glazed Stoneware Butter Keepers

This is the first glazed stoneware butter keeper that I recommend on this list. The glazed butter keeper can preserve butter better than the plastic one.

The butter keeper is shaped like a butter bell. The way it works is very simple. You only need to fill the top of the butter keeper with butter and pour about 1.25 cm of water into the basin and then, turns it upside down so the water will cover the top of the butter. The water in the base seals the butter from the air and keeps it fresh, soft and sweet.

You spread the butter easily over several times within 30 days without refrigeration. A little note is that you need to change the water about every 2-3 days to avoid the growth of bacteria.

Moreover, it is also an easy-to-clean product. You put it on the top rack of the dishwasher and wait until it is completely clean.

A special butter brings you a delicious and quick breakfast.

Product Specs

Trudeau 09607081A Butter Keepers

Different from the introduced products, the Trudeau 09607081A Porcelain Butter Boat has a unique and elegant design. This butter keeper is equipped with outstanding features to preserve it in the best condition.

Glazed porcelain butter boat keeper has a dual chamber design where butter is kept on the boat and water is kept at the basin under it. With this design, the butter is away from the water so you do not need to worry that the butter can slip into the water. Meanwhile, the steam will keep the butter at a constant temperature. In addition, the lid can also keep the butter away from the air.

With these advanced designs, butter is stored in the best condition so it is fresh, delicious and soft for a longer time.

The classic white design makes it elegant and suitable for all types of kitchen decor.

Changing water every 3-4 days is simpler because the butter is still kept on the boat. It is also safe with the dishwasher.

This butter keeper is a perfect product for those who loves luxurious, classic style with white color.

Product Specs

Le Creuset PG0200-0967 Butter Keepers

Although it resembles other butter keepers, this Le Creuset PG0200-0967 Butter Keeper is inspired by the original crock with a classic design.

The highlight of this product lies in its high quality material. The whole product is made from high-fired stoneware so it has good durability and can protect the crock from chipping, cracking and scratches. Non-porous enamel glazed layer adds durability to the product and resists to odor absorption. It also helps you to get butter and clean easily.

The way it works like any other butter keeper. It also uses water to seal out air and keep butter fresh. You should change water every 3-4 days for butter to be preserved longer.

Another plus point of this product is the water line inside the vasin. You can look there to see the amount of water needed to be poured inside.

I believe that with an airtight crock, the butter is kept fresh, soft and spreadable easily whenever you want.

Product Specs

KooK Ceramic Butter Keepers

The next item I would recommend on this list of top 17 best butter keeper is a ceramic one, KooK Ceramic Butter Keeper, which holds up to a standard butter stick.

This ceramic butter keeper has a sleek and modern design, with a flawless white finish that immediately attracts you with a classic appearance.

The handle is attached with the lid for easy gripping and lifting. It also has a rim on the base surface to prevent the lid from slipping into the butter when moving.

Elegant color, creative design and high quality are a good option to decorate at party and event tables.

Product Specs

The Original Butter Bell Butter Keepers

This original butter bell has an remarkable appearance with matte finish glazes and a wide range of colors. Its signature pattern in the crock body, which is cafe retro pattern, makes it outstanding and unique. The manufacturer has carefully focused on the body structure.

Like other butter keepers, this classic one has two parts, a bell-shaped lead and a crock as the bottom. Fill the lid with butter and pour about 1/3 of the water into the crock, after that, turn the lid upside down into the basin. The water that surrounds the butter bell protects butter from the harmful agents and keeps it fresh, soft, delicious and spreadable for 30 days.

Do not forget to change water every 2-3 days for the butter to be protected in the best condition. This product can be used for dishwashers so don’t worry about it.

I think this is a perfect option as a special gift for friends and family who love to cook!

Product Specs

OXO Good Grips Butter Keepers

This is the best plastic butter keeper I’ve ever introduced. The material is durable plastic, so it avoids falling and it is cleaned in a dishwasher.

The butter base comes with many useful features. A large butter dish stores more butter, even long or short stick. Its surface is designed to prevent the butter from slipping off tray and dirtying lid. The bottom stoppers keep the dish stable on the table when slicing. The two sides non-slip handles are for you to take a grip firmly and move it to a new place effortlessly.

Another special feature of this butter keeper is two tablespoon measurement markings for Western and Eastern style sticks, which support you to get enough butter.

The clear plastic lid makes it easy to check the amount of butter left on the plate.

An ultra-convenient butter keeper, you have no reason not to buy it!

Product Specs

SveBake Butter Keepers

I think this SveBake Butter Keeper does not disappoint you because it is cute, unique and functional.

If you are looking for a large capacity butter keeper, this one fits two butter sticks of any brand. It is a durable boat and long-lasting beautiful. Thanks to 5 layers enamel, butter dish is highly durable, resistant to stains and abrasion and will not lose its glam over time. Moreover, a thick layer enamel protects butter from bacteria and mold to keep it fresh and soft.

The natural beechwood lid is not only unique but also multifunctional. It can double as a cutting board or serving board.

I fall in love with a cute shape, modern design with a classic white and a navy blue rim. I think it’s ideal when you choose it as a distinctive gift for your friends or family.

In addition to keeping butter, you use it to store other foods like cookies, bread, chocolate, etc.

Product Specs

Sweese 304.101 Butter Keepers

The butter keepers work in the same way. They use water in the crock to prevent bacteria and air from damaging the butter. As a result, the butter is soft and fresh at room temperature.

This product is made of professional grade porcelain, which is a premium lead-free and non-toxic ceramic. Therefore, it is highly durable, chip-resistant and more sturdy than stoneware.

This butter bell has a bigger capacity than others. It holds up to 1.5 sticks of butter if you press it properly. It is suitable for most families.

A water line in the crock, which you look at to determine the amount of water to fill, makes an airtight seal.

It comes with many striking colors to make your kitchen look more eye-catching. It would be a wonderful gift along with the lovely box.

Product Specs

 Le Creuset PG0200-0916 Butter Keepers

This Le Creuset PG0200-0916 Butter Keeper is a original crock with a white classic design.

This product is made from a type of high quality material, which is high-fired stoneware. Therefore, it is highly durable, chip-resistant and non-scratch. It has a non-porous enamel glazed layer, which makes it resistant to odor absorption. It is also easy  to get butter and clean. That is a remarkable feature of the product.

This butter keeper uses water to keep butter at a stable temperature. Thus, you remember to change water every 3-4 days to avoid the growth of germs.

You can look at a water line inside the crock to determine the amount of water needed to be poured.

A classic white design is suitable for who loves vintage style.

A good quality butter keeper like this can help you enjoy these delicious dishes with soft butter.

Product Specs

Sweese 305.102 Butter Keepers

I think this is the best butter crock. It was designed to keep butter fresh and spreadable for weeks.

Its material is professional grade porcelain, which is completely safe for your health because it does not contain lead and chemical toxins. Beside, the porcelain butter keepers are more durable than the stoneware ones.

This Sweese butter keeper is quite smaller than Sweese 304.101 one, it holds up to 1 and 1/3 stick of butter. Even so, it is still enough for the needs of a family.

There are many colors to choose, outstanding colors such as red, orange, yellow or elegant colors such as white, turquoise, steel blue. Choose a color that matches your kitchen style!

One feature that I like about this product is that it is safe with dishwashers, ovens and microwaves. It saves your time and is much more convenient.

Product Specs

Butter Bay American Made Butter Keepers

This Butter Bay Butter Keeper looks like the French original butter crock, which has two items, a butter bay filled with the butter and a basin with water to make an airtight seal.

This product has a unique design to have extra butter storage space. The butter bay holds a whole cube of butter.

Butter is kept fresh and ready to spread for 3 weeks without refrigeration, if you change the water every 3-4 days to limit the growth of bacteria.

The butter keeper is manufactured 100% from the American, with advanced technology, to create a durable and sturdy butter bay. The product does not contain lead and cadmium so it is safe for health.

I think your kitchen needs something as striking as it to add interest. It is also a special gift for your friends on special occasions.

Product Specs

Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Keepers

This is the first glass butter keeper I recommend on this list. I am really impressed with its sleek appearance and quality.

This Luminarc Cow Butter Keeper is made from thick glass, which is heavy, heat resistant, cracking resistant and highly durable. Moreover, it is completely hygienic and wash resistant. When choosing this product, you don’t worry about its durability because it can serve you for a lifetime.

Besides, the lid not only separates the butter from the air, it can also keep the butter cool and fresh continuously during parties. You just need to put some crushed ice in the lid before placing the butter tray on top. It’s very handy.

The transparent glass makes it easy to check the amount of butter remaining. With this design, the butter does not slip off the tray when cutting.

This butter keeper is suitable for families or those who want a large storage space because it holds up to 2 butter sticks or 8 ounces of European style butter.

You can use it as a regular food container because it is designed to preserve food best.

Product Specs

Now Designs Butter Keepers

Are you interested in this butter keeper? I am interested in at the first sight. Because its shape is different from others.

If you get bored with butter crocks or boats, I think you will love this square butter dish. It’s perfect for square shaped butter. It looks modern and premium.

This square butter dish is made of stoneware, so it is very durable and strong. Thanks to that, you can use it in dishwasher and microwave without cracking or breaking.

There are slight burrs on the dish to prevent the butter from slipping off the dish, and dirtying the lid.

There is a small knob on the lid for you to take a grip and lift easily.

It comes with two elegant colors, eggshell blue and lemon yellow, for your choice.

Overall, it is worth being in your kitchen.

Product Specs

DOWAN Porcelain Butter Keepers

The last butter bell on the list comes from the DOWAN brand. I know this brand because it is famous and always brings the best kitchen products.

This butter keeper is made from top-grade lead-free porcelain, which is durable and safe for health. Hence, you can be assured of the quality of this product. It will always serve you well.

The water in the jar makes an airtight seal between lid and crock, which prevents air from reaching and spoiling the butter. As a result, the butter is kept soft and fresh at room temperature. It is ready for use with toast, bread, waffles, pancakes, and more.

I make sure that you immediately fall in love with trendy looks and eye-catching colors of butter bell at the first sight.

Product Specs

PREPWORKS Butter Keepers

At the end of the list of top 17 best butter keepers, I introduce to you the PREPWORKS Butter Keeper, a butter tray with many handy features.

You can place butter anywhere you want without damage, thanks to the silicone seal. When closed, the silicone seal holds it tightly to minimize the air approach to the butter. For that reason, the butter is stored longer.

A noticeable point of this product is the measurement marks on both sides of the dish. It helps you accurately measure the amount of butter when you need to cook, bake, or spread bread.

The cover is made of thick, transparent and durable glass. It’s easy for you to check how much butter is left in the tray.

These items are safe for the dishwasher, so you have no trouble cleaning at all.

Product Specs

The Ultimate Guide To Choosing Best Butter Keepers In 2020

I have recommended the best butter keepers above with detailed descriptions of each product’s characteristics. I hope they are useful for you as they help you choose the most suitable butter keeper.

If you want to be more certain with your choice, you should carefully consider the following criteria, which I use to evaluate and select the products that are recommended for you.

Type

Butter keepers are usually classified into two popular types: the French butter crock and the butter dish.

The French crock consists of two items, a crock of water and a butter bell above. Thanks to the water, butter is kept fresh for up to 30 days. At the first use, you have a little difficulty putting butter in the bell, but you will gradually get better. There is a point to note when using this type, which is that the water in the basin need to be changed every 2-3 days to make sure it is free of bacteria.

As for the butter dish, it’s a little easier to use, but there is a remarkable notice that you close the lid tightly so the butter doesn’t come into contact with the air. Typically, butter is kept fresh and smooth about 2-3 weeks.

In general, both types of butter keepers are good and always ready to spread. Whichever you prefer, choose that one

Material

The materials used to make butter keepers are considered to ensure good quality. The butter crocks is usually made from stoneware, porcelain, , and ceramic, while the butter dishes are usually made of plastic or glass.

Each type of material has its advantages. Products made from porcelain, ceramic, stoneware, glass are durable, easy to clean but can break. As for plastic, it is lightweight and harder to break.

You should consider when purchasing the product, which is suitable for your family’s condition.

Capacity

Popularly, butter keepers hold up a stick of butter, which is suitable for small families or those who do not regularly use butter.

If you have a bigger family or you use butter daily basis, it would be better to purchase a butter keeper, which can store 1,5 or 2 sticks of butter.

Design and feature

Manufacturers have come up with butter keepers in a variety of colors and designs. Choose a product that matches perfectly to your kitchen decor, classic or modern.

These products have also been improved with many convenient features such as non-stick handles, measuring markers, silicone seals, etc. They help you use the butter keeper simply and easily. As a result, they make your life more comfortable.

FAQs

Do butter crocks really work?

Yes, I think so. Those butter crocks do a good job of keeping butter fresh and soft for a long time.

How do you use a butter keeper?

As mentioned, there are two common types of butter keeper, the French butter crock, and the butter dish, with different uses.

With a French butter crock, you only need to fill the top of the butter keeper with butter and pour about 1.25 cm of water into the basin. Do not forget to change the water regularly so that bacteria do not damage the butter.

With a butter dish, it’s simple. You just need to put the butter on the dish and close the lid properly in order for the air doesn’t approach the butter.

Are butter keepers safe?

Yes, of course. They are safe for your health, dishwasher, or microwave, even an oven.

Does butter get wet in a butter bell?

No, the water does not mix with the butter. In some cases, the butter may fall into the water.

What is the best butter dish?

My pick is Butterie Flip-Top Butter Dish Keeper

How long does butter last in a French butter dish?

When you use a French butter dish, the butter is kept fresh, soft and can spread within 30 days.

Can you leave butter out all night to soften?

If you place the butter in a good butter keeper, it is kept soft and fresh for extended periods without spoilage.

Conclusion

These are my objective reviews of the best 17 butter keepers above. Now, you have to make your decision. I hope the specific instructions in the buying guideline will help you make the right choice.

In my opinion, the Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Dish is suitable for first-time users because it is quite simple and easy to use. If you want a greater one, the finer decision is the Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain.

If you need more information or more profound communication, leave a comment below.

Thank you for reading!